Dear Sampooran Singh Kalraji,
Sat Sri Akal!
Nobody has got any problem with why you have changed your name or why you are always seen in a white kurta-pajama only or why you don’t appear as the judge in reality shows or why you are so bad at socializing or why you have not changed with time (and that means not having “commercialized” your writings to the demands).
The problem is with what you write. I mean why can’t you write in simple language using simple words? When others say “chaand ki choodiya” then you say “chaand ka gubbara”, when others say “baag mein ek phool khila hai” then you say “chaddi pahen ke phool khila hai”, when others say “zameen par kadamo ke nishaan” then you say “main hawa pe dhoondho uske nishan” and many more examples are there which I cant include in my tiny blog. And by the way, is it possible to say to any girl that “teri kamar ke bal se, nadi muda karti hai”? Any girl with an iota of self-esteem will slap her lover thinking that he believes that she’s so gigantic that she can even guide the river path!
Why it always has to be so abstract that people have to listen carefully at least 3-4 times before they understand what is written. Only if they understand. And what’s with this excessive love for moon that people have started calling you “Moon man”? Every other song you write has a direct or indirect reference to moon. Yeah we know that moon traditionally has a big role in romantic Indian tales but wouldn’t it be simpler to tell a girl that you look like a “chaand ka tukda” rather than saying something that you have to spend next 10 minutes explaining the meaning of?
Indians can boast of having read/heard great poets from Kabir to the recent crop of “commercial” writers. Many poets here started with a great promise but later succumbed to the demands of producer/director and ended making themselves a poor shadow of their past. But from “Mora gora ang le le” to “Dil to bachcha hai jee”, you have been able to hold on to signature style. You think you are so brave. Don’t you?
I think you should have been banned just after your first few writings only so that the next generations would have been spared from the unnecessary mental exercise. Your poetry starts with a liking and then become an obsession that makes people to refuse to accept anything lesser than your standards. And then there are people like me who say that we like your poetry so that we would sound offbeat and the ones who have a liking for something really different and incomprehensible for common man. The other reason is to impress the girls who think that we are so sensitive and as you know, poetry is one of the ways to win that special one!
Gulzar sa’ab, I just have one request. Please keep writing. And one wish. Would like to have a drink with you someday.
This one is from your self-confessed “chela” and my senior:
Zarre-zarre mein usi ka noor hai,
Jhaank khud mein, wo na tujhse door hai,
Ishq hai uss se toh sab se ishq kar,
Iss ibaadat ka yahi dastoor hai,
Isme-usme aur usme hai wahi,
Yaar mera har taraf bharpoor hai